Senator Tammy Baldwin released the text of the Ending China's Special Treatment Act on November 17 and announced its introduction. Four earlier bills of this Congress would withdraw China's permanent normal trade relations (PNTR) treatment without saying whether Column 2 would replace the duties Chinese goods already owe or be added to them. On its face, Baldwin's text answers that. Section 3(a) would apply Column 2 rates to all products of China one year after enactment. Section 3(b) says those rates "shall be in addition" to other duties that apply to the same products under any other provision of law. The clause names no authority, though the bill's findings cite Sections 201, 301 and 232.
The U.S. International Trade Commission's August study of PNTR revocation observed that Section 301 duties are additions to Column 1 General and that "the HTS does not indicate that any additional column 2 duties would apply on those imports if NTR status were revoked." Two commissioners wrote in additional views that revocation would either replace the existing additional tariffs on China or add to them.
The treatment of existing Chapter 99 duties in the PNTR scenario is a field that Traverse's August comparison of China PNTR repeal paths had to hold open. For the import compliance manager who keeps the HTS-level China duty model, section 3(b) fills it for Baldwin's bill and for none of the other four.
The tariff schedule is not yet written to carry that answer. Each Chapter 99 heading has its own Column 1 and Column 2 rate cells, and the Section 301 headings for China state no added duty in Column 2. The bill supplies no Chapter 99 text for a Column 2 good, and its one product waiver lifts the Column 2 rate while leaving Chapter 99 duties in place. The bill is not law.
The Ending China's Special Treatment Act adds a sentence other bills lack
Section 3(a) follows the operative sentence of the 2022 statute on Russia and Belarus nearly word for word. That law was silent on other duties. It let the President proclaim rates above Column 2 and allowed a return to Column 1 on a presidential certification. Baldwin's text adds the sentence on other duties and has neither of those two features. Its only route back to Column 1 is the product waiver in section 3(d).
S. 3566 would apply Column 2 to all products of China 90 days after enactment and let the President proclaim higher rates. S. 206 and H.R. 694, which carry the same text, would have the President proclaim China-specific rates built on a Column 2 base. H.R. 1504, introduced in February 2025, would return China to title IV review and sets no rates. None of the four has a clause on other duties.
Chapter 99 prints the China surcharges three ways
Chapter 99 of HTS Revision 23, the edition in force on November 17, states a surcharge for a Column 2 good in some headings and not in others.
Where today's China surcharges sit if the goods move to Column 2
| Chapter 99 heading | Added in Column 1 General | Column 2 cell | Flag in the PNTR scenario |
|---|
| Section 301 Lists 1, 2, 3 and 4A (9903.88.01, 9903.88.02, 9903.88.03 and 9903.88.15) | 25%, with 7.5% on List 4A | Blank | Open, no Column 2 rate stated |
| Section 301 four-year-review tiers (9903.91.02 solar cells, 9903.91.03 electric vehicles, 9903.91.06 lithium-ion batteries) | 50%, 100% and 25% | Blank | Open, no Column 2 rate stated |
| Section 301 forced-labor duty on China (9903.05.31) | 12.5% | Base duty, no surcharge | Open, Column 2 states the base duty alone |
| Section 232 headings 9903.82.02 (steel, aluminum and copper) and 9903.94.01 (passenger vehicles and light trucks) | 50% and 25% | Same surcharge | Carries into Column 2 as printed |
The table covers selected headings in HTS Revision 23 as of November 17, 2026, and no China PNTR bill is enacted. The last column is Traverse's reading of the printed schedule, not a CBP ruling. Other Section 232 metals headings differ, and heading 9903.82.10 for derivative articles prints "No change" in Column 2.
U.S. notes 20 and 31 do not settle the point. Note 20(a) says all products of China in the listed subheadings are subject to the additional duty "imposed by heading 9903.88.01" and "shall also be subject to the general rates of duty imposed on products of China." Note 31(a) uses the same formula for the four-year-review headings. Under U.S. note 1 to the subchapter, a Chapter 99 rate applies in place of the ordinary rate to articles "for which rates of duty are herein provided." None of these notes mentions Column 2, and none says what a Column 2 good owes when that cell is blank.
Battery electric vehicles show how much depends on the answer. Subheading 8703.80.00 carries 2.5 percent in Column 1 General and 10 percent in Column 2. Heading 9903.91.03 adds 100 percent in Column 1 General and states nothing for a Column 2 vehicle, which is the gap section 3(b) addresses. On those rates, that 100-point addition matters far more than the 7.5-point step between the two columns.
Column 2 applied to Russian and Belarusian goods by statute from April 9, 2022. That June, Proclamation 10420 amended General Note 3(b), the schedule's list of Column 2 countries, citing section 604 of the Trade Act of 1974. A comparable instrument could write the Section 301 surcharges into Column 2, but the bill does not require one. It mentions an implementing proclamation only in section 3(c), which requires consultation with six congressional committees at least five days "before issuing a proclamation to implement subsection (a)." Russia's own 35 percent rate in heading 9903.90.08 applies "in lieu of" Column 2, so it is no model for the stack.
The waiver lifts only the Column 2 rate
Section 3(d) lets the President "waive the application of subsection (a)" for goods entering with an individual traveler and for "necessary manufacturing inputs and machinery identified under section 4(b)(3)." On that text, a waived input would go back to Column 1 General and keep its Chapter 99 duties, including any Section 301 surcharge not covered by an exclusion then in force. The 178 exclusions that USTR extended this month run only through January 9, 2027, before any waiver could take effect. Where it applies, the separate 12.5 percent forced-labor duty would remain as well.
The eligible inputs would come from a USTR-led interagency report that identifies inputs and machinery "exclusively or primarily available" from China. The report is due 270 days after enactment, following a comment period of at least 90 days. Column 2 rates would start about 95 days after that deadline. The text sets no criteria, procedure, deadline or duration for a waiver.
Four bills still need a replace case and an add case
For Baldwin's text, the Chapter 99 treatment field should read additive under section 3(b) of the bill, with each surcharge carrying its flag from the table. For the other four, the field should read that the bill does not address other duties. None of them touches the Section 301 actions. S. 3566 is the only one whose own text applies Column 2 as printed, and there the Section 301 rate cells state no surcharge. The model should carry a replace case and an add case for all four until bill text, a proclamation or an agency instruction picks one.
The text Baldwin released leaves its bill number blank, and no number had been posted as of November 17. S. 206, H.R. 694, H.R. 1504 and S. 3566 have not moved since referral. The 119th Congress ends at noon on January 3, 2027, and bills not enacted by then die. Associated Press race calls, as tallied by NPR, give Democrats both chambers of the next Congress, so the bill could return in 2027. The sponsor has not said whether it will.
A bill number and referral would confirm introduction, and an amended or reintroduced bill could add conforming HTS language or a waiver procedure. Any proclamation or USTR notice writing a Column 2 rate into a Section 301 heading would show how the schedule is meant to carry the stack.