A U.S. company that applies today to export H200-class chips to China already signs a statement about American manufacturing capacity. Under paragraph (dd)(1)(ii) of the January license policy, the applicant certifies that the shipment will not delay U.S. orders and that "global foundry capacity that would otherwise be used to produce similar node or more advanced integrated circuits for end users in the United States will not be diverted." The rule asks for "necessary supporting data" but never says what unit that data is measured in.
Two proposals now offer competing answers. The GAIN AI Act would ask whether U.S. buyers were offered the chips first and whether any U.S. order is waiting. The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission (USCC), in Key Recommendation VIII of its 2026 report released November 18, would extend the test upstream to advanced-node wafer fabrication, high-bandwidth memory and advanced packaging, "not finished-chip inventory alone," backed by auditable allocation data filed with the Bureau of Industry and Security. Neither proposal is law, but the paragraph (dd) certification is already in force, so the applicant's compliance lead has to decide now what record stands behind it. The safer file is built at the allocation level the Commission describes. It supports the foundry statement the company already makes and covers the inputs a broader reading would reach.
The H200 rule's capacity clause has no unit
The January rule, 91 FR 1684, moved chips below 21,000 total processing performance (TPP) and 6,500 GB/s of DRAM bandwidth, such as the Nvidia H200 and AMD MI325X, to case-by-case review for exports from the United States to China and Macau. It pairs two supply tests. The measured one caps aggregate TPP exported to China and Macau at 50 percent of the TPP the applicant has shipped to U.S. customers for U.S. end use, a cap examined in Traverse's review of H200 licenses and actual shipments. The unmeasured one is the foundry clause quoted above.
The rule's third-party lab requirement does not fill that gap. A qualified U.S. lab must review every shipment before export, and under paragraph (dd)(3) it confirms that the chip's TPP, DRAM bandwidth, interconnect bandwidth and copackaged memory are at or below the specifications in the application. BIS says only that it will "routinely confirm the accuracy of relevant elements" of the certifications "using any methods it deems appropriate."
The remote access rule BIS released on November 16 moves the case-by-case policy to 15 CFR 742.6(b)(10)(iii)(A)(2) when it is published on November 19. It leaves paragraph (dd) unchanged.
How the three capacity tests differ
Three U.S. supply tests for AI chip exports to China, compared as of November 18, 2026.
| Test | Status | Who certifies | What is measured | How it is checked |
|---|
| H200 license policy, Supp. No. 2 to Part 748 (dd) | In force since January 15, 2026 | Exporter applying for a China license | No delay to U.S. orders; no diversion of "global foundry capacity"; China TPP at most 50% of U.S. TPP per product | Lab confirms chip specifications only; BIS confirms certifications by unstated methods |
| GAIN AI Act, S. 3150 (House companion H.R. 5885, whose text differs, including its capacity wording) | Referred to committee; dropped from the enacted FY2026 NDAA | Exporter, as a condition of any license to a country of concern | U.S. right of first refusal for at least 15 business days; no current U.S. backlog; no foreseeable backlog or reduction in critical production capacity for 12 months; no better pricing for foreign buyers | BIS must deny a license filed without the certification; BIS rules on recordkeeping and misrepresentation penalties |
| USCC Key Recommendation VIII | Recommendation to Congress | Exporter of advanced AI chips to China | Diversion of wafer fabrication, high-bandwidth memory and advanced packaging capacity from the U.S. market, in addition to finished chips | Auditable capacity-allocation data filed with BIS; criminal penalties for false certification; annual BIS report |
GAIN measures the order book. Under proposed ECRA section 1758A(a)(2) in S. 3150, a backlog is a formally documented request from a U.S. person, such as a purchase order or contract, that the applicant will not be able to fill within commercially standard lead times. The test reaches comparable products made with "substantially similar production process, infrastructure, or supply," and the applicant must also state that it "cannot reasonably foresee" a reduction in critical production capacity over the next 12 months. It does not name memory or packaging, and it counts orders, not the split of input capacity.
The Commission's version adds the inputs to the measurement. Its Chapter 8 calls high-bandwidth memory "one of the most significant supply constraints in the AI hardware ecosystem," with buyers reserving capacity years ahead, and says advanced packaging "has become critical to AI chip production." An order book can show no unmet U.S. demand while the China-bound product still draws on memory and packaging slots that U.S.-bound products also need.
The upstream data sits partly with suppliers
A fabless designer controls its own reservations: wafer starts booked with a foundry, memory supply agreements and packaging slots. A full diversion test would also need the foundry's and memory maker's allocation across all their customers, which the designer does not hold.
BIS does not collect that supplier-side data today. The closest report, under 15 CFR 743.9, has front-end fabricators report each quarter the quantity of 3A090.a chips sold to authorized designers, part of the foundry due diligence regime. It counts finished units and says nothing about how capacity was divided. ECRA already lets the agency require information "from United States persons and foreign persons" under 50 U.S.C. 4813(a)(8), though collecting it from foundries and memory makers abroad would test that reach. Because the Commission puts the certification on the exporter, the exporter would in practice be the one assembling supplier evidence.
ECRA's existing industrial-base test does not settle the question. Section 4815(d) requires denial of exports with a "significant negative impact" on the defense industrial base, but ties that impact to national-security production for the Department of Defense and other federal agencies. Commercial demand for AI compute does not clearly fall within it, and both proposals would address that demand directly.
Build the file at the allocation level
The certification already carries legal risk. ECRA bars any "false or misleading representation, statement, or certification" to Commerce in 50 U.S.C. 4819(a)(2)(F). Civil penalties under section 4819(c) contain no intent requirement, and criminal penalties under section 4819(b) apply to willful violations. Section 4819(a)(3) also deems a certification "continuing in effect" and requires the exporter to tell Commerce of any material change, so the file has to stay current after the license issues.
For each pending or planned application, the support file for paragraph (dd)(1)(ii) should tie the China-bound units to the wafer lots, memory and packaging capacity they consumed, drawn from the company's own reservations. It should show the U.S. order book over the same period, with lead times, so the no-delay statement rests on dated records. Where a supplier confirms that capacity used for China-bound product was not taken from other U.S.-bound work, keep that confirmation with the application. That record speaks directly to the clause as written, and it is close to the capacity-allocation data the Commission recommends, which the report does not define further. A GAIN-style right-of-first-refusal notice would be a separate step, required only if Congress enacts it.
What would turn a proposal into a requirement
The Senate added GAIN as Subtitle H of its FY2026 defense bill, which passed 77 to 20, but the text was absent from the enacted law, Public Law 119-60. Neither the reported Senate FY2027 bill, S. 4784, nor the House-passed H.R. 8800 contains it.
The two Senate AI OVERWATCH texts, which already differ on whether existing chip licenses would be reset, also split on this point. A July 13 amendment to the Senate FY2027 bill, S.Amdt. 6575, which was submitted but, as of November 18, not adopted, would copy the H200 foundry clause into ECRA, still without a measure. Section 1758A(c)(1)(E) of S. 4456 would have BIS certify to Congress that a license "will not adversely impact the defense industrial base of the United States, including the availability of covered integrated circuits for United States persons," down to major subcomponents such as high-bandwidth memory. That would be the agency's certification, not the exporter's, and S. 4456 has sat in the Senate Banking Committee since April 30.
Five records would change this advice: a bill that carries the Commission's language, GAIN or OVERWATCH capacity text in a final FY2027 defense bill, BIS guidance defining the "supporting data" for paragraph (dd)(1)(ii), an amendment to paragraph (dd) itself, and the first enforcement action that cites a paragraph (dd) certification.