Judge Richard K. Eaton's November 13 order in Freestyle World states that the class action's commencement and the court's October 8 certification of the IEEPA refund class "had the effect of tolling the statute of limitations" for each class member's claims. For a class member below the complaint's original $1,000,000 cap that has not sued, that note removes the two-year limit in Section 2636(i) as a reason for a protective filing while the class stands. A suit filed now mainly takes the importer out of a mandatory class.
A compliance manager or trade counsel deciding whether to file needs two facts, class membership and the date its clock stopped. The July read of class tolling in V.O.S. told importers to treat their own deadline as the control date. Members below the cap can now work from the February 19, 2026 complaint date, while larger payers may face a later start.
The November 13 tolling note sits outside the decree
The note relies on American Pipe and Construction Co. v. Utah, where the Supreme Court held that a class action suspends the limitations period "as to all asserted members of the class." A footnote cites Section 2636(i), which runs two years from when a Section 1581(i) claim "first accrues."
The order's only ordering paragraph sets a CBP report for December 1 and a settlement conference for December 2. Freestyle World's November 10 motion for a class relief order asks the court to order tolling expressly, and its proposed order says all members' Section 2636(i) periods "are tolled."
The government's answer filed November 13 denies that the plaintiff is entitled "to any relief whatsoever" but pleads no limitations or accrual defense. Its response to the relief motion is due December 9 under the November 9 scheduling order, the next scheduled filing where a timeliness objection could surface.
The $1,000,000 cap could move the start date for larger importers
The February 19 complaint did not plead the class that was certified. Paragraph 64 limited it to importers that paid "less than $1,000,000." The cap disappeared in the June 23 certification motion, whose memorandum acknowledges in footnote 8 that the complaint covered small importers, and the October 8 opinion certified the uncapped class. RECAP shows no amended complaint, and the answer treats paragraph 64 as legal argument needing no response.
The later start is an interpretation of American Pipe's own words, which attach tolling to "asserted members" of the class. An importer above the cap was not an asserted member until the June 23 motion claimed it. Freestyle World's relief motion reflects the gap when it says the complaint tolled claims "for at least most importers."
A court could read the record the other way. The November 13 note dates tolling from commencement for "each class member's claims" without distinguishing groups. Paragraph 64 reserved a right to amend, and footnote 8 cites authority that a court "is not bound by the class definition proposed in the complaint." No court has chosen between these readings.
No filing in this case states when a Section 1581(i) refund claim accrues, so the arithmetic assumes accrual on the payment date. It uses February 4, 2025, when the China duties of Executive Order 14195 began applying to entered goods, as the earliest realistic payment, so each balance is the minimum for its group. The class covers payments under the "Challenged Tariff Orders," the orders the Federal Circuit held unlawful.
| Importer group | First filing claiming it | Assumed tolling start | Minimum unused time, February 4, 2025 payment |
|---|
| Paid less than $1,000,000 | Complaint, paragraph 64 | February 19, 2026 | 350 days |
| Paid $1,000,000 or more | Certification motion, ECF 12 | February 19, June 23 or October 8, 2026 | 350, 226 or 119 days |
| Paid after February 19, 2026, or under other IEEPA orders | ECF 70 and 70-2, not entered | None under the certified definition, or November 10, 2026 if the motion's assertion counts | Earliest lapse August 2027 if untolled, or 269 days left from November 10 for an August 6, 2025 payment |
On the asserted-member reading, the November 10 motion could itself start tolling for that last group, though no court has said so. The balances stay frozen while the class stands and matter only if it later narrows or fails. Crown, Cork and Seal Co. v. Parker holds that tolling continues "until class certification is denied." Extending that rule to decertification is an interpretation, under which a large importer with the earliest payments would keep about four to seven months, not almost a year.
Payments the certified class may not reach
The certified definition covers duties paid "between February 1, 2025, and February 19, 2026," yet CSMS #67834313 ended IEEPA collection only for goods entered on or after February 24, 2026. Periodic monthly statement filers pay on the 15th working day of the following month under the October 2025 PMS test notice, which CBP's 2026 calendar puts at February 23 for January entries and March 20 for February entries. Read by payment date, those payments fall outside the class, an inference since no filing or order construes the phrase.
Freestyle World's motion says importers that paid the Brazil and India duties under Executive Orders 14323 and 14329 already belong to the class because those duties sat on top of Executive Order 14257 duties. At the court's recommendation, though, it proposes covering "any duties imposed pursuant to IEEPA," and the proposed order says it does not address de minimis issues pending in a separate case. On payment-date accrual, the Brazil duties applied from August 6, 2025 and the India duties from August 27, 2025, so the earliest such claims would lapse in August 2027 if left outside the class, while March 2026 statement payments run into 2028.
When a separate suit still makes sense
The certification opinion holds that membership in a Rule 23(b)(2) class "is mandatory and fixed." The only exit is the exclusion for an entity that has separately sued, which Freestyle World reads to cover suits filed before or after certification. On that reading, filing means leaving the class and its eventual relief order.
Three situations can justify it. One involves finally liquidated entries, which CAPE does not accept from non-plaintiffs, as the certification opinion found. CBP's Phase 3 functionality serves plaintiffs whose reliquidation is court-ordered, yet a new plaintiff would need its own order and then join a rolling queue, since CBP says plaintiffs whose importer numbers arrived after August 27 gain access "at a later date." The pending relief motion would also open Phase 3 to the class.
An importer whose only IEEPA payments fall outside the certified definition loses no current membership by filing, though a suit would bar it from the broader class the plaintiff proposes. An importer with payments on both sides of February 19 leaves the class entirely if it sues over any of them, because the exclusion applies to the entity. A payer above the cap with the oldest payments may also prefer its own action to a disputed tolling start. For a member below the cap, an individual suit adds no limitations protection and gives up a class remedy that may reach entries never submitted to CAPE.
The December filings that could reopen the decision
An order granting the relief motion as drafted after the December 9 response would put tolling in an ordering paragraph and extend the class to every importer of record that paid IEEPA duties and has not sued.
The decision reopens if an order narrows, decertifies or limits the class, which on the Crown, Cork reading lets the clock resume on the unused balance for those removed, or if an accrual ruling moves the dates in the table. Until then, a class member's limitations file should record its tolling start, assumed accrual date and unused balance, and flag payers above the cap for counsel.