Applications for Further Review of Protest Nos. 0712-11-100112 and 0712-11-100128; Subheading 9801.00.10, HTSUS
Modified. CBP published the modification of this ruling in Customs Bulletin Vol. 60, No. 27 (Sep 9, 2026), by Headquarters ruling H325599 on CBP, effective for merchandise entered on or after Nov 8, 2026. Read the later ruling before citing this one.
Key passages, quoted from the ruling
- The protest should be granted with respect to the cutting tools, and denied for the remaining merchandise for the above stated reasons.
Ruling text
This is in response to the Applications for Further Review of Protest Nos. 0712-11-100112 and 0712-11-100128, filed on behalf of First American Resources Co. LLC (First American Resources), which pertain to the eligibility of cutting tools and their associated parts and accessories for duty-free treatment under subheading 9801.00.10, Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (HTSUS). Both entries liquidated on December 10, 2010, and we note that the protests were timely filed.
FACTS: This protest covers two entries of the same merchandise. It is claimed that the merchandise was originally exported from the U.S. by Arrowhead Industries Corporation (Arrowhead Industries) to Arrowhead Industries Canada (Arrowhead Canada) (now ACP-Canada) between 2002 and 2008. It is also claimed that the same goods were subsequently imported into the U.S. for trial production runs at a facility in the U.S. as part of the first entry on September 13, 2010.
The merchandise was sent back to Canada on September 21, 2010 and imported the second time on December 23, 2010. These entries consisted of: two (2) tool cutters twelve (12) roll tools six (6) roll stands five (5) guide support tables four (4) metal guides, and four (4) plastic nyloil guides. The goods were entered under subheading 9801.00.1095, HTSUS, in both entries.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) issued a CBP Form (CF) 28 on September 28, 2010 requesting, among other things, “An American Manufacturer’s Affidavit from the ACTUAL MANUFACTURER OF THE MERCHANDISE.” On November 22, 2010, CBP issued a CF 29 stating that the goods were rate advanced because, per a response from the importer, the merchandise was not U.S. goods returned, and therefore, subheading 9801.00.10, HTSUS, was not applicable.
In their protests, the importer states that in a follow-up phone call to the CF 28, an employee of First American Resources provided incorrect information regarding the origin of the goods to the Customs officer. It is stated that the employee did not realize the shipment contained U.S. and Canadian goods, and replied that the goods were Canadian because that was the country of export.
ACP-Canada claims that all the merchandise at issue was manufactured by Arrowhead Industries in Cleveland, Ohio, except the roll stands, which were fabricated by another manufacturer in Pennsylvania and shipped to Arrowhead Industries. No documentation was provided to support this claim. In support of their claims, the importer has submitted the following documentation for the merchandise at issue: An invoice from ACP Canada to First American Resources, dated September 10, 2010, (corresponding to the first entry).
The invoice appears to be priced in Canadian dollars (“$CDN”). The invoice lists, among other merchandise stated to be Canadian in origin, two (2) tool cutters, twelve (12) roll tools, six (6) roll stands, five (5) guide support tools, four (4) metal guides, and four (4) plastic nyloil guides. An invoice from ACP Canada to First American Resources, dated October 21, 2010, (corresponding to the second entry). This entry lists the same merchandise as the first, along with the same values.
The text above is an excerpt. The official ruling, with its letterhead, signature and any attachments, is on CBP CROSS (H175426).