Kitchen and household cleaning and maintenance products imported under consignment; Valuation under 19 U.S.C. § 1401a; Computed Value
No Headquarters ruling in this index revokes or modifies this ruling. That is not confirmation that it is still in effect: this index does not hold every Headquarters ruling. Confirm its current status with CBP before relying on it (ruling on CBP CROSS). Text last read from CBP on Nov 21, 2026.
Key passages, quoted from the ruling
- Based on the information submitted, the appraisement of the imported merchandise should be appraised under computed value pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § 1401a(e), provided the 6 importer is prepared to present CBP with documentation to support appraisement under this valuation method.
Ruling text
in response to your request, dated May 21, 2025, filed on behalf of your client, This is Caron Brands Inc. (“Caron”), requesting a prospective ruling regarding the proper appraisement of kitchen and household cleaning and maintenance products imported under consignment. In response to our requests for additional information, you submitted supplemental documentation in support of your request between February 18, 2026, and July 26, 2026.
FACTS: You state that Caron is a non-resident importer located in Canada and manufacturer of natural kitchen and household cleaning and maintenance products, such as cast iron oil, cast iron soap, cast iron salt scrub, wood oil, and leather oil, among others. These products are imported on consignment to Amazon for fulfillment services within the United States.
You explain that Caron has no contract with Amazon but rather, uses their Fulfillment by Amazon (“FBA”) services, which allow Caron to manage products they ship, the price they sell them for, and the amount of promotion they apply to them. Meanwhile, Amazon will handle the platform, payment, tax collection, fulfillment, warehousing, picking and shipping of the orders. By using this service, products may remain in inventory for months before they are returned to Caron, or are destroyed.
Regarding the relationship between Caron and Amazon FBA services, you explain that Amazon does not purchase inventory from Caron. Rather, Amazon charges service fees to Caron after the subject merchandise is sold to end arrangement, you customers. Upon our request for additional information regarding this submitted a copy of Amazon’s monthly invoicing to Caron.
This monthly statement reflects the service fees charged by Amazon, which you assert are not tied to the import invoice value and relate solely to post-sale service charges. You state that very limited commercial level sales are made directly to wholesalers and consumers from Caron’s website. Caron’s consignment sales through Amazon FBA services represent 80% of Caron’s total sales while direct (non-Amazon) sales represent 20% of its total sales.
Accordingly, you assert that the majority of Caron’s merchandise imported into the United States is not sold for export. This ruling only addresses the valuation of merchandise imported under consignment to Amazon’s warehouse. To demonstrate the limited direct sales to wholesalers and consumers from Caron’s website, you provided two representative invoices for wholesale transactions involving the various kitchen and household cleaning and maintenance products at issue.
For purposes of this ruling request, we will be relying on the cost amounts for the 8-ounce cast iron oil (“cast iron oil”). These invoices identify the wholesale price of the cast iron oil at $7.50 per unit. You also provided a copy of Caron’s sales sheet of its standard wholesale pricing, which confirms that the price per unit of the same product identified by the same item number from the invoices is $7.50.
For the subject merchandise that will be imported under consignment using Amazon FBA services, you propose the computed value method of appraisement.
The text above is an excerpt. The official ruling, with its letterhead, signature and any attachments, is on CBP CROSS (H349010).