First Sale; Multi-Tiered Transactions; Related Parties; Beverage Equipment
No Headquarters ruling in this index revokes or modifies this ruling. That is not confirmation that it is still in effect: this index does not hold every Headquarters ruling. Confirm its current status with CBP before relying on it (ruling on CBP CROSS). Text last read from CBP on Nov 21, 2026.
Key passages, quoted from the ruling
- The sale between Ningbo and MBS is not at arm’s length and therefore cannot constitute the basis for a first-sale appraisement under Nissho Iwai.
Ruling text
This is in response to your request of July 4, 2025, on behalf of your client, Marco Beverage Systems US (“MBUS”) for a prospective ruling on the use of “first sale” appraisement for imported merchandise. Your request, submitted as an electronic ruling request, was forwarded to this office from the National Commodity Specialist Division for response.
FACTS: The proposed multi-tier transaction involves three parties: (1) MBUS, the U.S. importer; (2) Marco Beverage Systems Ltd. (“MBS”), an Irish middleman; and (3) Marco Catering Equipment Ningbo (“Ningbo”), a Chinse manufacturer. All three entities are “related parties” for purposes of customs valuation.
The sample transaction outlined in your submission involves a “countertop tap boiler,” which is designed for compact and energy-efficient hot water dispending in low-volume applications such as cafes, offices, and catering stations.
The following documents were provided for our review: • A purchase order from MBUS to MBS for 24 units of the merchandise, along with a corresponding order confirmation, indicating shipment to MBUS in the United States; • A purchase order from MBS to Ningbo for 24 units of the merchandise, along with a corresponding order confirmation, indicating shipment from Ningbo to MBS in Ireland; • An invoice from MBS to MBUS, with a delivery location in the United States and the annotation that “[a]ll goods are sold on the understanding that the title of the goods does not pass to the purchaser until such time as any debt to Marco Beverage Systems by the 1 purchaser has been discharged in full, regardless of whether the debt is associated with the present transaction or otherwise”; • An invoice from Ningbo to MBS, with FOB Ningbo terms and shipment to the United States; • A bill of lading for the merchandise, indicating shipment by sea from Ningbo, China to Vancouver, Canada, with a place of delivery in the United States; • An invoice from the freight forwarder to MBUS corresponding to the bill of lading; • Proof of payment by MBUS for the goods and freight-forwarding services; and • Proof of payment by MBS for the goods.
In response to our request for information establishing that the transactions were conducted at arm’s length, you provided a “memorandum for benchmarking study” that was prepared for Ningbo by an accounting firm.
The text above is an excerpt. The official ruling, with its letterhead, signature and any attachments, is on CBP CROSS (H350676).